Related Articles

5 Comments

  1. 1

    Fred

    I never had to think about it, because here in Germany you don’t find that kind of questions in a questionaire. They would be considered privacy violations.

    A physician will ask those questions in a personal conversation, if there is a valid reason to assume a sexually transmitted disease.

    Maybe you should consider this as another example of the sometimes rather peculiar idea of “freedom” in the USA . . .

  2. 2

    Dr. Phil

    Actually, had you answered those questions in the way you jokingly said you would have, it would have been honest, right? (And perhaps have even brought a smile to the face of the data entry person who got your file.) None of what you may have written is politically incorrect, insensitive, or culturally loaded. And because the only person who could possibly be “made fun of” in your comments is you, which makes it a whole different thing.

    (If I said to a waitress “Can I ask you for another beer? I know, I am a dirtbag, but I really want one,” that would be self-deprecating and perhaps amusing to her; if I said to the guy ordering a beer at the next booth “Wow, you’re a dirtbag!” that would be rude and offensive; and if I said to the waitress who just took an order for another beer from the guy at the next booth, “Wow, he’s a dirtbag!” that would be inappropriate and also rude.)

    As for those questions on the intake survey: they are there so they can get as accurate a sense of your own health situation as possible. They fit the data in them into an algorithm that would rule out and rule in certain situations given your particular symptomology, etc. (If you’re sexually active, it could make the difference between a diagnosis like “urinary tract infection” and “gonorrhea,” which I think you’d agree is a big difference!) They don’t ask those things to “be personal” or to “pry,” it is so they can provide the best information to you and to themselves as possible in assessing what is ailing you and how they might best be able to assist you to get better.

    In any case, I’m glad to hear that the cut healed with not too much difficulty (besides the $226, which is actually somewhat reasonable for the U.S. healthcare system, but still sucks, certainly…).

  3. 3

    Pete25

    I have never had those questions posed to me when I went to a new physician and I think I would have been as incensed as you were. If when the physician sees you he feels he needs the answer to that type of question then that is his time to ask especially as the problem was not related to that part of your anatomy.
    Agree with Dr. Phil that your healing quickly is a good thing.

  4. 4

    dd-bos

    I’m not as witty as you, Dave, so my answers wouldn’t have nearly been as comical as yours were. I’d have been too embarrassed to answer them honestly, and likely would have lied or toned the answers down to something that wouldn’t have raised too many eyebrows at the hospital.

    But I’m also not as callous as you, and using the word “fairy” to refer to or address another gay man is equivalent to calling him a “faggot” in my book, and shows nothing but disrespect. I know you got a lot of crap for that post, some deserved and some over the top. But I don’t recall actually ever seeing an outright apology or an acceptance that what you said was uncalled for. I’ve been reading your blog for years, and I’ve got to admit, I lost a bit of respect for you on that one. Maybe it’s a cultural difference between Americans and Aussies, but we’re fighting for equality here in the U.S., and a gay or bi man addressing another gay man in such a fashion is a step in the wrong direction, whether in jest or otherwise. This invites others, straight, bi or otherwise, to use hurtful language because when they hear others (especially within the gay community) use it, it is inadvertently deemed acceptable when it is not. I’ll continue to read your blog, because I believe in giving people the benefit of the doubt and offering second chances. But please don’t do it again.

  5. 5

    Hungspeedoguy

    Better than my sexual health checkup experience in Thailand!
    http://www.becomeavagabond.com/sexual-health-check-in-thailand/

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *